1.2.3.7. Doubling of the wh-sign

Doubled constructions are marked sentences in which some element is repeated in final position. In the case of wh-signs, doubling this element in a content interrogative results in a partial question with two equal, coreferential wh-signs. The doubling could be explained as a means to receive prominence or emphasis. A content interrogative with a doubled wh-sign differs from a multiple wh-interrogative [SYNTAX 1.2.3.8]; the first construction requires only a single element as their answer, while the second one requires a pair list.

 

                                                    wh

            what john steal what

            โ€˜What did John steal?โ€™

(based on Alba, 2016: 100)

 

The actual distribution of the wh-expressions in doubled constructions can only be:

 

-       Initial plus final position, or

-       Base plus final position.

 

The spreading of non-manual markings over the components to the left of the first wh-sign is optional. However, the appearance of a wh-sign in an initial or in its base position triggers the obligatory spreading of non-manual marking to the end of the clause.

 

 

a)         Initial + final position

                                          wh

what john steal what

            โ€˜What did John steal?โ€™

 

b)        In situ + final position

           (      )                       wh

john what steal what

            โ€˜What did John steal?โ€™

(examples a-b based on Alba, 2016: 100-101)

 

Complex wh-expressions (wh-sign plus a restrictor) can also participate in doubled wh-interrogatives. Regarding their distribution, the behavior is the same one observed for simple wh-expressions. At least one of the two wh-expressions must occupy the final position of the sentence. The other one may be in initial position or in situ. Non-manual markings must cover all the material between the two wh-expressions.

 

                                                                     wh

            whisky which john drink whisky which

            โ€˜Which whisky does John drink?โ€™

(based on Alba, 2016: 105)